• About Brother André Marie, M.I.C.M.
  • About Reconquest, the Radio Show

RECONQUEST, with Brother André Marie

~ Seeking that which was lost… and fighting for it.

RECONQUEST, with Brother André Marie

Category Archives: Natural Law

The Natural Law in Medical Ethics

22 Saturday Sep 2007

Posted by Brother André Marie, M.I.C.M. in Medical Ethics, Moral Theology, Natural Law

≈ Leave a comment

The natural law tradition as explicated by Saint Thomas Aquinas is foundational for Catholic medical ethics. Here is a very brief description of the Natural Law theory of Thomas Aquinas as it affects that field of moral theology. Included in the description are (a) the historical antecedents of Natural Law, (b) the remote and proximate foundation of Natural Law, (c) the specification of the first principle and precept of Natural Law, (d) the formulation of the specific principles of Natural Law, and (e) the limitations as the movement to made from general principles to contingent action, and (f) the response of the Natural Law position to a particular issue in medical ethics.

According to St. Thomas, the natural law is “nothing else than the rational creature’s participation in the eternal law.” Continue reading →

Catholics, Non-Catholics, and the Natural Law

30 Thursday Aug 2007

Posted by Brother André Marie, M.I.C.M. in Apologetics, Moral Theology, Natural Law

≈ Leave a comment

Given the general decline in public morals, and given the fact that, as an institution, the major promoter of the natural law is the Catholic Church, some are led to conclude that the natural law is a “Catholic thing,” or that it only binds Catholics. The natural law is Catholic inasmuch as it is an integral part of the Catholic moral system, but it is not a subject of the supernatural revelation that Christ bequeathed to His Church. It is something given to all men as strictly binding.

Even Catholics are confused about this and think that, as long as a non-Catholic follows his conscience, he is not bound to the natural law. But this goes against scripture (as well as the notion of what a conscience is): St. Paul said “when the Gentiles, who have not the law, do by nature those things that are of the law; these having not the law are a law to themselves” (Romans 2:14). This is generally interpreted to mean that those who did not have the benefit of the revelation of the Old Testament (specifically the Mosaic Law) were still naturally endowed by their Creator with consciences capable of judging good and evil. The next verse goes on to say that these pagans show “the work of the law written in their hearts, their conscience bearing witness to them, and their thoughts between themselves accusing, or also defending one another.”

That the moral law binds all men is a truth of the Catholic Faith universally believed. While many churchmen are confused and confusing on the issue, the Church still officially teaches this (indeed she cannot cease doing so). Vatican II, in its Gaudium et Spes, speaks of this law written on the heart: “In the depths of his conscience, man detects a law which he does not impose upon himself, but which holds him to obedience. Always summoning him to love good and avoid evil, the voice of conscience when necessary speaks to his heart: do this, shun that. For man has in his heart a law written by God; to obey it is the very dignity of man; according to it he will be judged.”[1]

This conciliar passage footnotes passages from St. Thomas’ Summa Theologica (II-II, q. 32, a. 5 ad 2; and q. 66, a. 2) where the Angelic Doctor affirms that all human beings, not only Catholics, know the eternal law of God to the extent that they know the universal principles of the natural law. So the council fathers clearly had in mind the universality of the natural law. The teaching is not unique to St. Thomas: “The general teaching of theologians is that the supreme and primary principles [of the natural law] are necessarily known to every one having the actual use of reason.”[2] This is why everyone knows, for instance, that murder is wrong.
To the non-Catholic who may claim that natural law does not bind him because it is “Catholic,” I would propose the following:

  1. “Do good and avoid evil” – the first precept of the natural law – is found in the legal codes, philosophical works, religious books, and literary monuments of all civilizations, ancient and modern.
  2. Many of the secondary precepts of the natural law – e.g., prohibitions of murder, theft, and adultery – are found in those same historical records, such as the Code of Hammurabi, the ancient Babylonian legal code.[3]
  3. Much of modern literature, which seeks to be “value free,” is filled with stories of the bitterness of guilt which visits those who violate their consciences in matters of the primary and secondary precepts of the natural law.

In short, the common experience of mankind acknowledges the universality of the natural law.

But there is more. Obedience to the natural law is necessary, but it is not enough to make man truly right or just. Supernatural revelation is needed to make man right, both to heal him of Original Sin and to elevate him to attain his final goal, which is a supernatural end. The natural law, which is naturally knowable, can help to bring someone into the Catholic Church. Especially nowadays, as fewer institutions stand up for the natural law, those with a good will, who earnestly seek to keep that law, can see that the law written on their heart corresponds to the moral law defended by the Catholic Church.

According to Dr. John Haas, “The approach of the natural law helps us enter into dialog with other peoples who may not share our particular religious beliefs. The natural law and the doctrine of the Catholic Church tell us that the Church’s basic moral teachings, whether they have to do with euthanasia, contraception, or the ways in which one wages war apply to everybody.”[4]

This truth can help us to evangelize. How? First, it is foundational, as we have said, that the natural law applies to all men and that all have a knowledge of its fundamental precepts. Second, the Church’s moral teachings conform perfectly to this law. Therefore, since all men know these principles in some degree, they will see the basic moral teachings of the Church as good and reasonable; therefore, the natural law provides a moral terminus a quo from which to begin in our conversations with non-Catholics.

Building upon that, we acknowledge, with St. Thomas and most other theologians, that there will be confusion about the application of the secondary principles of the natural law. Now, as St. Thomas teaches in the Summa Contra Gentiles, those who desire knowledge also desire to flee ignorance[5] and that which is imperfect desires to be perfected.[6] Therefore, people in pursuit of greater clarity, knowledge, and understanding of the law that is written in their hearts – if their pursuit be accompanied by a resolute good will – will see the reasonableness of those moral teachings of the Catholic faith, teachings which clarify the secondary precepts of the natural law.

This, of course, could be a grace leading to their conversion.

Footnotes

[1]Gaudium et Spes, No. 16. Translation on Vatican web site: http://www.vatican.va/archive/hist_councils/ii_vatican_council/
documents/vat-ii_cons_19651207_gaudium-et-spes_en.html (emphasis mine).

[2]The Catholic Encyclopedia, Volume IX, (Robert Appleton Company: 1910) http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/09076a.htm.

[3]Class notes, “Lecture 2: Natural Law.” http://home.comcast.net/~icuweb/c00502.htm.

[4]Ibid.

[5]III, 50, 6.

[6]III, 50, 2.

Listen to the CRUSADE CHANNEL of the Veritas Radio Network now!

Veritas Radio Network

CLICK HERE FOR THE LIVE (LOW BANDWIDTH) FEED.

(VRN Members get the high-bandwidth feed.)

HOW DO I LISTEN TO RECONQUEST?

Sign Up for Our E-Newsletters

Like what you see?

Then click here, or on the image, above, to sign up for the «AD REM», my fortnightly newsletter. You can also get our bookstore notices, too.

View previous issues of «AD REM».

Buying or Selling a Home?

Choose Real Estate for Life and Help This Apostolate. Click on the image below!

Dedicated to the Holy Family…

To Our Lord Jesus Christ the King, one of the Holy Trinity, who has supreme dominion over all creation.

To the Holy Virgin Mary, the Mother of God, and our Queen and Mistress.

To Saint Joseph the Betrothed, Patron and Protector of the Universal Church, and model of Christian manhood.

Follow Reconquest via Email!

Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Facebook Page

Facebook Page

Follow me on Twitter

My Tweets

Listen to Archived Episodes

  • Episodes 1-10
  • Episodes 11-20
  • Episodes 21-30
  • Episodes 31-40
  • Episodes 41-50
  • Episodes 51-60
  • Episodes 61-70
  • Episodes 71-80
  • Episodes 81-90
  • Episodes 91-100
  • Episodes 101-110
  • Episodes 111-120
  • Episodes 121-130
  • Episodes 131-140
  • Episodes 141-150
  • Episodes 151-160
  • Episodes 161-170
  • Episodes 171-180
  • Episodes 181-190
  • Episodes 191-200
  • Episodes 201-210
  • Episodes 211-220
  • Episodes 221-230
  • Episodes 231-240
  • Episodes 241-250
  • Episodes 251-260
  • Episodes 261-270
  • Episodes 271-280

Recommended Sites

  • Saint Augustine Institute of Wisdom Learn the Catholic Faith!

RSS feed: Catholic Store Catholic Store

  • The Philosophy of Life - see pictures for condition
  • The Traditional Mass: An Oasis of Catholicity in a Desert of Modernism
  • The Catholic Sacramental Economy: Oasis of Salvation
  • ‘Three’ Must Be a ‘Thing’
  • On-Air
  • Making the Family an Oasis of Sanity
  • Lessons from the Middle Ages for a Saner Society

Recent Posts: Catholicism.org

Why ‘Great Means’ Means Great Things

The Most Zealous Doctor Illuminates the Easy Way to Eternal Happiness Good Facts and Good Acts Many people think of prayer as a pleasant pastime, an eccentric extra, or a holy hobby. They take a vague and poetic view of … Continue reading →

Reconquest 537: Real Love versus the Ecumenical Counterfeit

Reconquest Episode 537 debuted on Wednesday, November 11, at 7:00 PM. The topic is Real Love versus the Ecumenical Counterfeit. This episode is also available as a podcast on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Amazon Podcast, and Podcast Index. Resources: Everything Hangs on These — … Continue reading →

Report: 30% of US Bishop Funded Groups Promote Abortion, LGBT Ideology, or Marxism

Ahead of this weekend’s CCHD collection, the Lepanto Institute urges Catholics to keep their money out of the basket. Washington, DC (The Lepanto Institute) – Just days before parishes across the country take up the annual collection for the Catholic Campaign … Continue reading →

Reconquest 536: ‘Poetic Knowledge’ vs. the ‘Suicide of Thought.’ Guest: Dr. Robert Keim

Reconquest Episode 536 debuted on Wednesday, November 4, at 7:00 PM. The topic is ‘Poetic Knowledge’ vs. the ‘Suicide of Thought.’ My guest is Dr. Robert Keim. This episode is also available as a podcast on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Amazon Podcast, and Podcast Index. … Continue reading →

Reconquest 535: The Culture of Death and the Culture of Betrayal. Guest: Joe Doyle

Reconquest Episode 535 debuted on Wednesday, October 28, at 7:00 PM. The topic is The Culture of Death and the Culture of Betrayal. My guest is Joe Doyle. This episode is also available as a podcast on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Amazon Podcast, and … Continue reading →

RSS feed: Mike Church Mike Church

  • MCS #2481 Federal Aviation, Federal Failure
  • MCS #2480 The Crime of Being a Southern Belle
  • MCS #2479 Say Hello to the Demoncrats 3rd World Invasion
  • MCS #2478 Celebrate The Crusade Channel’s 11th Birthday!
  • MCS #2477 All the President’s Men (and Women)

Social

  • View brother.andre.marie’s profile on Facebook
  • View Brother_Andre’s profile on Twitter
  • View brotherandre’s profile on Pinterest
  • View BrotherAndre’s profile on LinkedIn

Listen to the Veritas Radio Network Now!

Click here to do so: HTTP://VERITASRADIONETWORK.COM/PLAYER/

Powered by WordPress.com.

Loading Comments...