• About Brother André Marie, M.I.C.M.
  • About Reconquest, the Radio Show

RECONQUEST, with Brother André Marie

~ Seeking that which was lost… and fighting for it.

RECONQUEST, with Brother André Marie

Category Archives: Vatican II

Father Z on the ‘Feeneyites’

29 Friday May 2009

Posted by Brother André Marie, M.I.C.M. in Fr. Leonard Feeney, St. Benedict Center, and Friends, Vatican II

≈ Leave a comment

Recently brought to my attention is this posting by Father John Zuhlsdorf (“Father Z”). In it, the popular Wanderer writer and Internet peritus presents some thoughts on relations between the SSPX and the Holy See. While some may consider that Father Z is glossing over the real issues and addressing only superficialities, I would have to agree with him — at least on the issue of practical paths to canonical normalcy for traditionalist groups.

The theological disagreements, without being papered over, can be discussed calmly where and when the “atmosphere” and “climate” has changed. Continue reading →

The Four Kinds of Magisterial Statement and the Various Responses Catholics Owe to Each

03 Thursday Jan 2008

Posted by Brother André Marie, M.I.C.M. in Ecclesiology, Magisterium, Vatican II

≈ Leave a comment

A much more in depth treatment of this subject is found in our “The Three Levels of Magisterial Teaching.” The discrepancy in numbering the levels (three vs. four) is explained by the fact that some theologians, apparently following Cardinal Avery Dulles (The Craft of Theology: from Symbol to System), have created a fourth category that is not in the magisterial documents which outline these different categories. Toward the end of this paper, I explain where I think they get this.

The four kinds of magisterial statement are (1) infallible dogma, (2) definitive statements on matters closely connected with revealed truth, (3) ordinary teaching on faith and morals, and (4) ordinary prudential teaching on disciplinary matters. Continue reading →

Vatican II and Phenomenology

15 Saturday Dec 2007

Posted by Brother André Marie, M.I.C.M. in Church History, Vatican II

≈ Leave a comment

Catholic Family News has just published an informative article in the form of a book review. The review, by Paul Zarowny, Ph.D., delves into the phenomenological method of the Council Fathers, as studied by the Passionist priest, Father John F Kobler (Vatican II, Theophany and the Phenomenon of Man: The Council’s Pastoral Servant Leader Theology for the Third Millennium).

Doctor Zarowny is no lightweight. Continue reading →

Vatican II and the Levels of Magisterial Teaching

20 Tuesday Nov 2007

Posted by Brother André Marie, M.I.C.M. in Ecclesiology, Magisterium, Vatican II

≈ 1 Comment

This is another offering from the larger work from which I earlier excerpted “The Three Levels of Magisterial Teaching.” As I said concerning that entry, this is a work in progress, being a section of a larger study on the various levels of magisterial teaching, the assent due to each, and where Vatican II fits into these categories.

Further explanations are needed here. The larger work focuses on ecumenism, specifically, the contents of Vatican II’s Unitatis Redintegratio (UR). Also, at the end of this piece I have put my complete bibliography, for one reason mainly, viz., some of the footnotes may not be entirely useful without the missing parts of the study. Those trying to figure out a reference may find the bibliography helpful. Please keep in mind that this is an academic paper. Many of the books referenced are not works I would recommend. In fact some of them are rubbish worthy of a good, old-fashioned book burning.

I could add to the collection of quotations on the authority of Vatican II the recent statement of Cardinal Biffi: ““John XXIII yearned for a Council that would achieve the renewal of the Church not through condemnations, but using the ‘medicine of mercy.’ By abstaining from reproving error, the Council would by this very means avoid formulating definite teachings that would be binding for all. And in fact, it held consistently to this initial direction.” (See “Before the Last Conclave: What I Told the Future Pope” by Sandro Magister.)

“…the magisterium ordinarium, is liable to be somewhat indefinite in its pronouncements and, as a consequence, practically ineffective as an organ.”

– P.J. Toner, “Infallibility” in the 1910 Catholic Encyclopedia Continue reading →

The Three Levels of Magisterial Teaching

10 Saturday Nov 2007

Posted by Brother André Marie, M.I.C.M. in Ecclesiology, Magisterium, Vatican II

≈ Leave a comment

Introduction: This is a work in progress. It is a section of a larger work on the various levels of magisterial teaching, the assent due to each, and where Vatican II fits into these categories.

According to standards presently employed by the Holy See and codified in Canon Law, there are three kinds of magisterial statement, three levels of authoritative teaching which establish the “the order of the truths to which the believer adheres.” Continue reading →

Vatican II: Some Clarity, Please

18 Thursday Oct 2007

Posted by Brother André Marie, M.I.C.M. in Ecclesiology, Magisterium, Modernism, Sacred Scripture and Tradition: Sources of Revelation, Vatican II

≈ Leave a comment

Recently, I witnessed a very animated discussion between a Scripture scholar and a religion teacher. The subject of the disputation was Biblical inerrancy. The scholar is a highly intelligent man, but a liberal. (In fairness to him, I must say that he avoids the more ridiculous ideas of biblical scholars, such as the fantastic “Q Gospel” theory.) The religion teacher is less knowledgeable than the scholar, but is not a liberal.

To protect the identity of the scholar, I shall call him “Ray,” after the notorious Raymond Brown, whom he seems to like. To protect the identity of the religion teacher, I shall call him “Tom,” after Tomás de Torquemada, the fifteenth-century Spanish Inquisitor, who he seems to like. Continue reading →

Listen to the CRUSADE CHANNEL of the Veritas Radio Network now!

Veritas Radio Network

CLICK HERE FOR THE LIVE (LOW BANDWIDTH) FEED.

(VRN Members get the high-bandwidth feed.)

HOW DO I LISTEN TO RECONQUEST?

Sign Up for Our E-Newsletters

Like what you see?

Then click here, or on the image, above, to sign up for the «AD REM», my fortnightly newsletter. You can also get our bookstore notices, too.

View previous issues of «AD REM».

Buying or Selling a Home?

Choose Real Estate for Life and Help This Apostolate. Click on the image below!

Dedicated to the Holy Family…

To Our Lord Jesus Christ the King, one of the Holy Trinity, who has supreme dominion over all creation.

To the Holy Virgin Mary, the Mother of God, and our Queen and Mistress.

To Saint Joseph the Betrothed, Patron and Protector of the Universal Church, and model of Christian manhood.

Follow Reconquest via Email!

Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Facebook Page

Facebook Page

Follow me on Twitter

My Tweets

Listen to Archived Episodes

  • Episodes 1-10
  • Episodes 11-20
  • Episodes 21-30
  • Episodes 31-40
  • Episodes 41-50
  • Episodes 51-60
  • Episodes 61-70
  • Episodes 71-80
  • Episodes 81-90
  • Episodes 91-100
  • Episodes 101-110
  • Episodes 111-120
  • Episodes 121-130
  • Episodes 131-140
  • Episodes 141-150
  • Episodes 151-160
  • Episodes 161-170
  • Episodes 171-180
  • Episodes 181-190
  • Episodes 191-200
  • Episodes 201-210
  • Episodes 211-220
  • Episodes 221-230
  • Episodes 231-240
  • Episodes 241-250
  • Episodes 251-260
  • Episodes 261-270
  • Episodes 271-280

Recommended Sites

  • Saint Augustine Institute of Wisdom Learn the Catholic Faith!

RSS feed: Catholic Store Catholic Store

  • The Catholic Sacramental Economy: Oasis of Salvation
  • ‘Three’ Must Be a ‘Thing’
  • On-Air
  • Making the Family an Oasis of Sanity
  • Lessons from the Middle Ages for a Saner Society
  • Building Fortresses in Enemy Territory
  • Fortes in Fide

Recent Posts: Catholicism.org

From Hole…to Home

Why have the Sisters dug ourselves a hole? What’s going on out here? Haven’t you heard that we were forced to evacuate our convent in July of 2024? It was mold. Bad mold. We are not exactly homeless — we … Continue reading →

A Cardinal and a Bishop Go at It Over Evangelism. Who’s Right?

As if we needed proof that the evil sort of ecumenism is very much alive, a rare public dispute happened recently between a cardinal and a bishop. To name them by the colors of their proper fascia,1 “Team Scarlet” was … Continue reading →

Copperfield and Heep

A Character Study (Spoiler Alert: This piece contains some major character/plot giveaways from the book, David Copperfield. I definitely recommend reading that novel before this essay on it.) As a teacher I appreciate the difference between merely giving a student … Continue reading →

The Fifth of the Four Last Things

There is an old line about how five out of four people do not understand fractions. That lack of perception might also pertain even to some who believe in what the Church deems “The Four Last Things” — death, (particular) … Continue reading →

Still Tory After All These Years

Confinement hail! in Honour’s justest Cause True to our King, our Country and Our Laws Oposing Anarchy, Sedition, Strife And every other Bane of Social Life These Colonies of British freedom tired Are by the Phrensy of distraction fired Surrounding … Continue reading →

RSS feed: Mike Church Mike Church

  • MCS #2475 One, Two, Dems Are Comin’ For You…
  • MCS #2474 Conservative’s Mission: Defeat the Cult of Trump
  • MCS #2473 The Day the MAGA Died
  • MCS #2472 How Big is Today’s Blue Wave Gonna Be?!
  • MCS #2471 The New “October Surprise”!

Social

  • View brother.andre.marie’s profile on Facebook
  • View Brother_Andre’s profile on Twitter
  • View brotherandre’s profile on Pinterest
  • View BrotherAndre’s profile on LinkedIn

Listen to the Veritas Radio Network Now!

Click here to do so: HTTP://VERITASRADIONETWORK.COM/PLAYER/

Powered by WordPress.com.

Loading Comments...